Schedules of reinforcement are two task statements in Concepts and Principles, a domain that accounts for 24 questions (14%) of what the Board Certified Behavior Analyst (BCBA) exam scores. Task B.9 asks you to identify and distinguish among simple schedules, and B.10 among concurrent, multiple, mixed and chained ones. These 10 questions name the schedule behind a token for every fifth worksheet, the response pattern of a variable-interval schedule, the flat-then-steep cumulative record of a fixed ratio, praise every 5 minutes whatever the student does, colored cards that signal two alternating schedules and two activities on different schedules at once. The others apply the matching law to VI 30-second and VI 90-second attention, set a first NCR interval from the interresponse time, thin hand-raising with a multiple schedule and run an interval DRO by the rules.
Question 1
A BCBA observes a student in a general education classroom. The student engages in both raising their hand appropriately and calling out answers. Data collected over 5 sessions shows that hand-raising is reinforced by teacher attention on a VI 30-sec schedule, while calling out is reinforced on a VI 90-sec schedule. The student's responses occur in an approximate 2:1 ratio (hand-raising: calling out). Given the teacher's limited capacity to provide attention, how should the BCBA interpret this response allocation using the matching law?
- A) The student is maximizing reinforcement by primarily engaging in the behavior with the denser schedule.
- B) The response allocation demonstrates undermatching, as the response ratio (2:1) is less extreme than the reinforcement ratio (3:1).✓
- C) The response allocation demonstrates overmatching, as the response ratio (2:1) is more extreme than the reinforcement ratio (3:1).
- D) The student's behavior is not governed by the matching law, as both responses are maintained by the same reinforcer.
Show rationale
Correct: The matching law predicts that the ratio of responses allocated to two alternatives equals the ratio of reinforcement obtained from them. Here, the reinforcement ratio for hand-raising (VI 30-sec) to calling out (VI 90-sec) is 3:1 (90/30 = 3), meaning hand-raising should be reinforced 3 times more frequently. The observed response ratio is only 2:1. This less extreme response ratio compared to the reinforcement ratio indicates undermatching (Option B). Option A is incorrect; maximization would involve exclusively choosing the denser schedule, not a proportional allocation. Option C is wrong; overmatching would show a response ratio more extreme than the reinforcement ratio (e.g., 4:1). Option D is incorrect; the matching law applies to concurrent schedules maintained by the same reinforcer (teacher attention), even when densities differ. Undermatching often occurs in applied settings due to factors like response effort or imperfect discrimination.
Question 2
A student receives math instruction where independent worksheet completion is reinforced on a fixed-interval 2-minute schedule when a green card is placed on the desk. When a red card is placed on the desk, completion is reinforced on a continuous reinforcement schedule. The conditions alternate successively throughout the session, and each colored card remains visible only during its corresponding schedule. Which schedule of reinforcement does this arrangement illustrate?
- A) Mixed schedule consisting of alternating schedules lacking correlated discriminative stimuli
- B) Tandem schedule requiring completion of successive schedules without correlated discriminative stimuli
- C) Chained schedule requiring responses across successive components to produce primary reinforcement
- D) Multiple schedule consisting of alternating basic schedules signaled by correlated discriminative stimuli✓
💡 Key Takeaway
A multiple schedule consists of two or more alternating basic schedules, each signaled by an explicit, correlated discriminative stimulus.
Show rationale
Multiple schedule consisting of alternating basic schedules signaled by correlated discriminative stimuli is the correct choice because a multiple schedule presents two or more basic schedules of reinforcement successively and independently, with each component schedule uniquely signaled by a distinct, correlated discriminative stimulus. In this classroom vignette, the fixed-interval schedule is signaled by the green card and the continuous reinforcement schedule is signaled by the red card, establishing clear stimulus control across schedule changes. Mixed schedule consisting of alternating schedules lacking correlated discriminative stimuli is incorrect because a mixed schedule contains alternating components without any accompanying discriminative stimulus to signal which reinforcement contingency is operative. Chained schedule requiring responses across successive components to produce primary reinforcement is incorrect because chained schedules mandate that components occur in a predetermined sequential order, where completion of one component serves as the discriminative stimulus for the next until terminal reinforcement is delivered. Tandem schedule requiring completion of successive schedules without correlated discriminative stimuli is incorrect because tandem schedules require sequential completion of multiple schedules without signaling stimuli.
Question 3
A BCBA is designing an intervention for an 8-year-old student who engages in screaming and disruptive behavior during independent seatwork. A functional behavior assessment confirms that the behavior is maintained by escape from academic tasks. Baseline data indicate that disruptive behavior occurs an average of 12 times per 60-minute session (mean interresponse time of 5 minutes). Which initial noncontingent reinforcement (NCR) schedule is MOST appropriate to implement?
- A) A fixed-time (FT) 4-minute schedule delivering a brief break from academic tasks✓
- B) A fixed-time (FT) 10-minute schedule delivering a brief break from academic tasks
- C) A fixed-time (FT) 4-minute schedule delivering access to preferred edible items while work continues
- D) A fixed-interval (FI) 5-minute schedule delivering a brief break after the student completes one task
Show rationale
A fixed-time (FT) 4-minute schedule delivering a brief break from academic tasks is correct because best practice for establishing a noncontingent reinforcement (NCR) schedule requires setting the initial time-based interval at or slightly below the baseline mean interresponse time (IRT) and delivering the functional reinforcer maintaining the target behavior (Cooper, Heron, & Heward, 2020; BACB Test Content Outline: Behavior Change Procedures). With 12 occurrences per 60 minutes, the mean IRT is 5 minutes (60 min / 12 = 5 min). An FT 4-minute schedule provides noncontingent escape prior to the expected occurrence of disruptive behavior, thereby weakening the motivating operation (MO) for escape. A fixed-time (FT) 10-minute schedule delivering a brief break from academic tasks is incorrect because an FT 10-minute schedule sets the interval significantly higher than the baseline IRT (5 minutes). This would result in insufficient reinforcement density, allowing the establishing operation to remain high and problem behavior to occur before reinforcer delivery. A fixed-time (FT) 4-minute schedule delivering access to preferred edible items while work continues is incorrect because it uses an arbitrary/non-functional reinforcer (edibles) rather than the maintaining reinforcer identified in the functional assessment (escape from demands). A fixed-interval (FI) 5-minute schedule delivering a brief break after the student completes one task is incorrect because an FI schedule is a contingent reinforcement schedule requiring a specific target response (task completion) after the interval elapses, whereas NCR requires response-independent (time-based) delivery on an FT or VT schedule.
Question 4
A behavior analyst is consulting in a 3rd-grade classroom. The teacher reports that a student frequently engages in calling out answers without raising his hand, which appears attention-maintained. The analyst recommends a non-contingent reinforcement (NCR) intervention to reduce the behavior. The teacher implements a procedure where she delivers brief praise to the student every 5 minutes, regardless of his behavior at that moment. After one week, data show a significant decrease in calling out. Which schedule of reinforcement best describes the procedure the teacher implemented?
- A) Fixed-interval schedule (FI)
- B) Fixed-ratio schedule (FR)
- C) Variable-interval schedule (VI)
- D) Fixed-time schedule (FT)✓
Show rationale
Correct: The correct answer is D because reinforcement (praise) is delivered on a fixed-time (FT) schedule – every 5 minutes – independent of the student's behavior. This is the defining characteristic of FT schedules used within NCR. Option A (FI) is incorrect because reinforcement in FI schedules is contingent upon the first response after the fixed interval has elapsed; here, praise is given regardless of any response. Option B (FR) is incorrect as reinforcement depends on a fixed number of responses, which is not the case. Option C (VI) is incorrect because the interval varies unpredictably in VI schedules, whereas here it is fixed at 5 minutes. The decrease in calling out occurs because the FT schedule provides the reinforcer (attention) non-contingently, abolishing the motivating operation for attention-seeking behavior.
Question 5
A BCBA is designing a maintenance plan for Liam, a 7-year-old student whose disruptive classroom behavior (calling out) was successfully reduced using DRA (differential reinforcement of alternative behavior: raising hand) on an FR1 schedule. The behavior is maintained by teacher attention. The teacher can consistently deliver attention but struggles with complex procedures. The BCBA aims to thin reinforcement to a manageable level while preventing resurgence, ensuring Liam's hand-raising remains high and disruptions low. Which schedule thinning procedure is MOST appropriate to implement next?
- A) Continue DRA on FR1 indefinitely to maintain current gains.
- B) Implement a fixed-time (FT) schedule delivering attention non-contingently every 5 minutes.
- C) Thin the DRA schedule gradually to a fixed-ratio (FR) 5 schedule.
- D) Introduce a multiple schedule using distinct discriminative stimuli (SDs) for reinforcement availability (green card) and extinction (red card), gradually increasing the duration of the extinction component.✓
Show rationale
Correct: The multiple schedule (D) is optimal because it uses explicit SDs to signal when reinforcement is available for hand-raising (green card) and when it is not (red card/extinction). This builds stimulus control, teaching Liam the specific conditions under which reinforcement occurs, which is crucial for maintaining the alternative behavior during thinning. It allows systematic, gradual increases in extinction intervals (schedule thinning) while minimizing frustration and resurgence, aligning with the teacher's need for clarity. Option A fails to thin reinforcement, risking dependency and not teaching tolerance for delayed reinforcement. Option B (FT) delivers attention non-contingently, ignoring the functional replacement behavior and potentially reinforcing disruptive behavior accidentally. Option C (FR thinning) risks ratio strain (increased disruptions if the ratio increases too quickly) due to the attention function and lacks clear signals about reinforcement availability, making it harder for Liam to discriminate when his behavior will be reinforced.
Question 6
A behavior analyst implements an intermittent schedule of reinforcement to maintain math worksheet completion for an adolescent. The analyst delivers praise and tokens for the first completed problem following intervals that average five minutes, though individual intervals range randomly from one to nine minutes. Which pattern of responding is this reinforcement schedule designed to produce?
- A) A high, steady rate of responding with little or no pause
- B) A constant, low-to-moderate rate of responding without post-reinforcement pauses✓
- C) A post-reinforcement pause followed immediately by an abrupt, rapid run rate
- D) A scallop pattern featuring accelerating rates near the conclusion of each interval
💡 Key Takeaway
Variable-interval schedules produce stable, low-to-moderate response rates with minimal to no post-reinforcement pausing.
Show rationale
A variable-interval schedule delivers reinforcement for the first correct response emitted after an elapse of time that varies around a specified mean. Because the individual cannot predict when an interval will lapse, this schedule typically generates a constant, low-to-moderate rate of responding with little to no post-reinforcement pause. The option describing a constant, low-to-moderate rate without pauses is correct. The option describing a high, steady rate of responding with little or no pause characterizes a variable-ratio schedule, which ties reinforcement directly to response count rather than time. The option describing a post-reinforcement pause followed by an abrupt, rapid run rate describes the classic break-and-run pattern characteristic of a fixed-ratio schedule. The option describing a scallop pattern with accelerating response rates near the end of the interval describes responding under a fixed-interval schedule, where the predictable passage of a uniform time interval produces pausing followed by gradual acceleration as the delivery window approaches.
Question 7
A teacher implements a token economy where a student earns one token immediately upon completing every fifth math worksheet during independent work time. The student works steadily, but the time taken to complete each set of five worksheets varies significantly across sessions based on worksheet difficulty. Based solely on the token delivery rule described, which simple schedule of reinforcement is in effect for earning tokens?
- A) Fixed Interval (FI)
- B) Fixed Ratio (FR)✓
- C) Variable Ratio (VR)
- D) Fixed Duration (FD)
Show rationale
Correct: The correct answer is FR because the token is delivered immediately after a fixed number of responses (completing five worksheets), regardless of time. This matches the FR schedule definition. Option A (FI) is incorrect because reinforcement depends on the first response after a fixed time period, not a fixed number of responses. Option C (VR) is incorrect because the ratio is consistent (every 5 worksheets), not variable. Option D (FD) is incorrect because reinforcement is contingent on engaging in behavior for a fixed period, not completing a set number of responses. The varying time between reinforcer deliveries is irrelevant; only the response requirement defines the schedule here.
Question 8
A behavior analyst observes a cumulative record for a student working on an instructional software program. The record displays a distinct flat line immediately following the delivery of every backup reinforcer, followed by a sudden shift to a steep, steady slope that persists until the next reinforcer is earned. Which schedule of reinforcement generated this data pattern?
- A) Variable-interval schedule, which maintains a stable, moderate response rate across all sessions
- B) Fixed-ratio schedule, which produces a post-reinforcement pause before a steady run rate✓
- C) Fixed-interval schedule, which produces an accelerating scallop pattern across each uniform interval
- D) Variable-ratio schedule, which maintains rapid rates without scheduled pauses between reinforcers
💡 Key Takeaway
Fixed-ratio schedules characteristically generate a post-reinforcement pause followed by a high, uninterrupted run rate.
Show rationale
A fixed-ratio schedule requires the completion of a predetermined, unvarying number of responses to produce reinforcement. This schedule characteristically produces a break-and-run response pattern: a post-reinforcement pause (represented by the flat line on a cumulative record immediately following reinforcer delivery), followed by an immediate return to a high, constant run rate of responding until the next criterion is satisfied. The option identifying a fixed-ratio schedule is correct. The option citing a variable-ratio schedule is incorrect because variable-ratio schedules produce consistent, high response rates without predictable post-reinforcement pauses due to the unpredictable response requirement. The option citing a fixed-interval schedule is incorrect because fixed-interval schedules generate an accelerating scallop pattern rather than a steep, immediate run rate following the pause. The option citing a variable-interval schedule is incorrect because variable-interval schedules generate stable, low-to-moderate response rates without pauses.
Question 9
A BCBA is observing a student in a classroom setting. The student has two activities available simultaneously: completing math worksheets on a Variable Interval (VI) 2-min schedule for teacher attention and playing an educational computer game on a Fixed Ratio (FR) 5 schedule for tokens. The student freely switches between activities without any signal from the teacher. Which schedule arrangement is this an example of?
- A) Multiple schedule
- B) Mixed schedule
- C) Chained schedule
- D) Concurrent schedule✓
Show rationale
Correct: The scenario describes a concurrent schedule (D) because two distinct reinforcement schedules (VI 2-min for worksheets, FR 5 for the game) are available simultaneously, and the student can freely choose between them at any time without an external signal. A multiple schedule (A) alternates schedules but uses distinct discriminative stimuli (SDs) for each, which are absent here. A mixed schedule (B) also alternates schedules but lacks SDs; however, the schedules are not presented simultaneously. A chained schedule (C) requires completing a sequence of responses in a specific order under different SDs to access reinforcement, which does not match the free-choice setup described.
Question 10
A behavior analyst designs an intervention plan to decrease frequent stereotypic hand flapping exhibited by an elementary student during independent academic periods. The analyst decides to implement a 3-minute fixed-interval differential reinforcement of other behavior (DRO) schedule. How should the classroom paraprofessional implement this intervention to ensure strict adherence to the defining mechanics of interval DRO?
- A) Deliver the reinforcer whenever the student engages in appropriate on-task academic work.
- B) Deliver the reinforcer immediately following the emission of a functional replacement response.
- C) Deliver the reinforcer only if hand flapping is absent throughout the interval.✓
- D) Deliver the reinforcer if hand flapping is absent at the three-minute mark.
💡 Key Takeaway
Interval DRO delivers reinforcement contingent on zero occurrences of the target behavior throughout the entire specified interval.
Show rationale
Under an interval differential reinforcement of other behavior (DRO) schedule, reinforcement is delivered contingent on the target problem behavior being omitted throughout the entire specified interval. If the target response occurs at any point during the interval, reinforcement is withheld for that interval. Delivering the reinforcer only if hand flapping is absent throughout the interval correctly applies this rule. In contrast, delivering the reinforcer if hand flapping is absent at the three-minute mark describes momentary DRO, which only evaluates the presence or absence of behavior at the precise conclusion of the interval rather than across its duration. Delivering the reinforcer whenever the student engages in appropriate on-task academic work characterizes differential reinforcement of alternative behavior (DRA), not DRO, because reinforcement is contingent upon a specific alternative response. Delivering the reinforcer immediately following the emission of a functional replacement response similarly reflects DRA or functional communication training (FCT). Interval DRO reinforces the non-occurrence of the target behavior without requiring any designated replacement response.
BCBA Simulator Pro
What the full simulator adds
- ✓Each explanation walks through the reasoning behind the answer, so you can spot the same idea when a new vignette dresses it up differently
- ✓All 525 questions are filed under the 9 domains of the BACB’s current 6th-edition outline, from philosophical foundations to personnel supervision
- ✓3 practice tests of 175 questions in 227 minutes: the real exam’s scored-item count at its average minutes per item, without the 10 unscored items, terms or tutorial it adds
- ✓A score for each domain, plus a 70% readiness line that is our own target: the real exam is pass/fail and the BACB publishes no passing percentage
$29.99 lifetime · or $9.99/month
🛡️ 30-day money-back guarantee · secure PayPal checkout · cancel anytime
📚 10+ years publishing exam-prep books · 150,000+ books sold✅ BACB BCBA exam outline · current for 2026