Question 1
A psychologist is the sole practitioner in a remote rural county. A local judge orders a competency evaluation for a current client who has been in weekly psychotherapy with the psychologist for major depression. What is the most ethical response?
▸ Why D is the answer
The most ethical response is to decline the evaluation. Mixing clinical and forensic roles with the same individual creates a severe multiple relationship that impairs objectivity and risks harming the client. Even in rural areas where resources are scarce, forensic evaluations require an independent examiner. Option A is incorrect because maintaining strict boundaries cannot neutralize the inherent bias of evaluating your own therapy client. Option B is incorrect because terminating therapy to conduct an evaluation is an unethical sequential multiple relationship that constitutes client abandonment. Option C is incorrect because performing the evaluation without submitting a report still violates role boundaries and fails to fulfill the court's order, serving neither the client nor the legal system effectively. Key Takeaway: Even in rural settings, psychologists must avoid mixing clinical and forensic roles for the same client.